Menu:

 

So I'm knocking out the drawer for my shop desk tonight. Simple stuff, right? I mean I've done dozens of these so no problem. I sized all of the drawer parts just a shaving or two over sized to allow for fitting the drawer to the desk later. I scribed all of the baselines, laid out the tail cuts on the sides, gang cut the tails and cleaned out the waste. The tails were looking pretty good and I was pretty happy with myself so I decided to press on even though it was a long day and I was getting pretty tired. I figured if I could just get the pins cut I could glue up the box tonight and it would be ready to fit a bottom tomorrow.

So I transfer all of my tails to their corresponding pin board being careful to pay close attention to orientation of the boards. On to cutting the pins. All was going well (or so I thought) until I got to my last corner of pins. That's when I realized it. I had cut the pins on the previous three corners on the wrong side of the line. Test fitting the sides into the front and back confirmed my unexcusable mistake.

I actually made two mistakes in my overconfidence and haste. The first mistake was a very foolish one made simply by being in a hurry. I did not mark the waste side of the line with big Xs like I usually do. This led to my second mistake, cutting the pins on the wrong side of the line. So I ended up with one nice dovetailed corner and three corners with gaps the size of the Grand Canyon (ok, maybe not that big, but still).

I guess the morals of this story are pretty obvious.

1. ALWAYS  mark the waste, even if you think you don't need to. No matter how many times you've done a particular operation, it only takes one dumb mistake to put your ego right back where it belongs.

2. NEVER work when you're too tired. Even though I'm not going to accidentally cut off an appendage with hand tools (I'd have to be pretty determined), there can still be some pretty serious consequences. I'm lucky I just made a mistake on my project, however, a simple misplaced hand during a paring cut or an improperly secured workpiece can still result in a pretty serious injury, even with hand tools. (As a side note, didn't we just finish Woodworker's Safety Week?)

I don't think I'm going to remake any of the parts of the drawer. Instead, I'll use them and repair the mis-cut joints as best as possible. This will serve as a constant reminder of my mistake and hopefully dissuade me from making it again.

There is one positive that can be gotten from this though. I have my next blog topic all set up for me.....how to fix loose dovetail joints.

 


Comments

Sun, 24 May 2009 04:34:55

If you were to use contrasting veneer to fill the gaps then it could look pretty nice, actually.

M.Mike

 

tico vogt

Sun, 24 May 2009 18:04:01

Years ago I was busy at work in my basement shop, building my Frank Klaus workbench, and was really in a productive groove one afternoon, when a voice came wafting from the floor above about coming upstairs to deal with some situation or other. I was in the process of sawing out some major dovetails for the tail vice. Everything was going along so well that I said to myself "no need to mark the waste, I'll remember which side of the line to saw on." Fifteen minutes later I returned to my sawing and, sure enough, sawed on the wrong side of the line. The repair with a thin shim is no big deal, but it is truly a daily reminder to make hatch marks on the waste. As Alan Peters has pointed out, it takes such little time!

 

Tue, 26 May 2009 05:37:36

Mike,
That's a good idea and would look interesting, just not my style. Plus, I didn't intend on the gaps so they aren't very even.

Tico,
You are of course 100% correct. It does take such little time to mark the waste. Certainly much less than the hour or so I spent making and fitting little shims to fit the gaps. As you said, the shims are no big deal but should not have been necessary and would not have been had I simply taken the couple of seconds it would have taken to mark the waste.

Bob

 



Leave a Reply

    Categories

    All
    Antiques
    Carving
    Design
    Hardware
    Layout
    Planes
    Podcast
    Projects
    Saws
    Sharpening
    Tools
    Turning
    Workbench
    Workshop



    Archives

    November 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    July 2009
    June 2009
    May 2009
    April 2009
    March 2009
    February 2009
    January 2009
    December 2008
    November 2008
    October 2008
    September 2008
    August 2008
    July 2008



    Useful Links

    Woodwright's Shop
    Sawmill Creek
    Woodcentral
    Woodnet
    SAPFM
    Hand Saw Filing
    How to Sharpen Edge Tools
    Unplugged Shop



    Hand Tool Retailers

    Tools for Working Wood
    Traditional Woodworking
    The Best Things
    Clark & Williams
    Wenzloff Saws
    Lie-Nielsen
    Lee Valley Tools
    Adria Tools



    Lumber & Supplies

    Hearne Hardwoods
    Irion Lumber
    Mr. Robert's Lumber
    Horton Brasses
    White Chapel Ltd.
    Londonderry Brasses
    Tremont Nail
    Old Fashioned Milk Paint Co.
    Real Milk Paint Co.



    Blogroll

    RSS Feed