Menu:

A Silly Idea? 12/10/2008
 

So there I go again. Thinking! It's always dangerous when that happens. But there I was reading "The Woodwright's Guide" and thinking. Thinking about wood; thinking about tools; thinking about furniture. But what really stuck in my mind this time was the format of the book, of all of St. Roy's books for that matter. His style of writing is so very well thought out and continuous (and witty, smart, etc.).

When you read any of the Woodwright's books, you are taken from the basic beginning and up through projects or processes with increasing complexity as the book progresses (e.g. from felling the tree straight through making a piece of furniture). As I contemplated this, it occured to me that this is what is missing from a lot of woodworking instructon media. Sure, there are tons of books on tuning up hand tools, how to use a table saw, how to build shaker furniture (with measured drawings of course). But I've yet to see one source that takes you through these things from start to finish. You are left on your own to put all the pieces together from several different sources. This includes most video instruction and classes as well.

So I had this silly idea that I could put together something using several short videos (maybe 10 minute each). Each video would build on the previous one like a mini apprenticeship but centered around an actual project. I could put the videos right here on the web site so people could check them out whenever they wanted, for free. I wouldn't just show how to set up a plane or sharpen a chisel. Rather I would actually walk through the recommendation I have made numerous times to folks seeking hand tool advice on several of the message boards. Specifically, I'll pick a project, acquire and tune the tools needed for that project and then build it. I'll use the process of building the project to demonstrate the techniques rather than just showing a video of a technique (like hand cut mortise and tenon for example) without applying it to an actual piece of furniture.

Of course this would be geared toward those just starting out in the craft or power tool folks wanting to incorporate more hand tool work. I certainly don't claim to be an expert by any means so experienced folks might not learn much from the videos (but you never know).  It might be something that the seasoned wodworkers might like to watch just to get a good chuckle though. If anything, you'll likely get to see me bleed and be able to tell your kids "See kids, here's an example of what not to do". It would probably be more entertaining than prime time television anyway.

So what do you think? How silly am I being? Would anyone actually be interested in something like this or am I that out of touch? Leave me a comment if this is something you'd be interested in seeing. If there is enough interest, perhaps I'll persue the idea after I finish my current project. If there isn't a lot of interest, that's ok too. There are plenty of other foolish things I can come up with the next time I get to thinking.

 


Comments

Jamie Bacon

Wed, 10 Dec 2008 08:58:10

Count me in as one who would eagerly log on to watch your videos. I have been a power tool woodworker for about 20 years and in the past year, have found myself drawn more and more into hand woodworking. I've acquired a couple turn of the century Distons, some old chisels, wooden try, jack and smooth planes (LOVE the feel of a wooden plane), etc. So yes, I would definitely be an eager audience to your videos. I really hope you persue this. Jamie Bacon

 

rfrancis

Wed, 10 Dec 2008 12:37:44

With Roy's books you cannot judge a book by its cover - the content is much better than the outside especially with the last one.
I would join your apprenticeshop too.
Had you thought of combining with Woodtreks Keith Cruikshank - he has all the production values you could ever want and lots of experience. And if you got on - what a team.

 

Bret Nelson

Thu, 11 Dec 2008 13:41:21

Count me in too! You have been an inspiration to me in since I found your "Let's Build Something Together" post on Sawmill Creek. I am rebuilding a 1870's Kansas farm house with hand tools and would very much appreciate any videos you produce. Keep up the good work!

Bret

 

John E.

Thu, 11 Dec 2008 18:58:54

I'd love this kind of thing, Bob -- I've been pretty down on a lot of the forums lately only because it seems like no one ever builds anything.

By the way, I thanked you way back when for the "Let's Build Something Together" thread, and in doing so I think I said I'd try building something like it--umpteen months later, I finally did start my ~1/3-scale version of that cabinet. I call it my PractiCabinet. Coming along swimmingly, and with no measuring--all relative dimensioning. Pretty liberating, and way more enjoyable than following a recipe.

So yeah. I support the idea of a new guided build.

John

 

simonm

Mon, 15 Dec 2008 04:28:32

Hi Bob - count me in. A great idea. If you could achieve the standard you set with the "Cabinet for the Shoppe" project it would be a fantastic resource.

 

Berl Mendenhall

Sat, 24 Jan 2009 09:29:29

Bob,
I would be very interested in the video series. I'm a newcomer to Sawmill Creek but have been a hand tool lover for many years. You have a special talent.

Berl

 

Mon, 26 Jan 2009 11:12:11

I would be interested in this video series as well if you choose to proceed.

Enjoying all that I've read here so far, and looking forward to more.

 



Leave a Reply

    Categories

    All
    Antiques
    Carving
    Design
    Hardware
    Layout
    Planes
    Podcast
    Projects
    Saws
    Sharpening
    Tools
    Turning
    Workbench
    Workshop



    Archives

    November 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    July 2009
    June 2009
    May 2009
    April 2009
    March 2009
    February 2009
    January 2009
    December 2008
    November 2008
    October 2008
    September 2008
    August 2008
    July 2008



    Useful Links

    Woodwright's Shop
    Sawmill Creek
    Woodcentral
    Woodnet
    SAPFM
    Hand Saw Filing
    How to Sharpen Edge Tools
    Unplugged Shop



    Hand Tool Retailers

    Tools for Working Wood
    Traditional Woodworking
    The Best Things
    Clark & Williams
    Wenzloff Saws
    Lie-Nielsen
    Lee Valley Tools
    Adria Tools



    Lumber & Supplies

    Hearne Hardwoods
    Irion Lumber
    Mr. Robert's Lumber
    Horton Brasses
    White Chapel Ltd.
    Londonderry Brasses
    Tremont Nail
    Old Fashioned Milk Paint Co.
    Real Milk Paint Co.



    Blogroll

    RSS Feed